A Great Journey:
Ubiquitous Approach on SMARTcard based Transport Fare
Management in Bangladesh
Azad1, Fahim
Tasneema1*, Mutiatur Rasul2, Ummay Sumaiya2**
1Lecturer, School of
Business and Economics, United International University, Bangladesh
2Lecturer,
Faculty of Business Administration, Eastern University, Bangladesh
*Corresponding Author E-mail: tasneema.azad@yahoo.com
**E-mail: mutiatur.fba@easternuni.edu.bd
ABSTRACT:
Modern technology has radically transformed the
process of fare management and transport booking around the world. Bangladesh -
with its high population density - faces numerous problems in ensuring constant
per unit rate of fare, timely transportation booking and proper queue
administration. The absence of a ubiquitously applicable SMARTcard
system in transportation increases the likelihood of black ticketing and price
hike in holiday seasons. The research paper thus gives an insight into the
necessity of SMARTcard approach in context of
Bangladesh; analyze the fare management pattern by urban consumers and
utilizing that information builds a prototype model which can be applied in
public transportation - be it roads, waterways, railways or even domestic
airways - by the concerned governmental authority to reap the benefits of a
modern travel method. The research in this way is beneficial for the public and
private sector enterprises engaged in the transportation sector and might be
useful for further researches into nation-wide digitalized travel management.
KEY WORDS: Transport, SMARTcard, ticketing, booking, fare, toll, passengers,
travel management.
With
the changing scenario of mobility, information, new technologies in human life
and faster living style to suit the 21st century’s official and
personal needs, the demand for a well-managed and advanced transportation
system is required for any economy to grow. The population dynamics, security
issues, availability of transports and modality of arranging transportation
thus greatly affects the daily life and convenience of a passenger. Unsuitable,
risky or uncertain transport can easily effect people’s productivity, time
scheduling and interestingly, stress levels. Thus, a sound transportation
policy coupled with the possibility of applying modern technology to ensure
faster, secure system is very important. Especially for a least developed
country like Bangladesh with pressure of excess population hurting the
conventional transportation module to a near breakage, adapting to a more
streamlined method of transportation booking and payment is a burning issue. In
neighboring countries bearing similar population pattern, several attempts and
action plan has been administered which has met with success. For example, Seoul
Metropolitan Government has restructures their public transport modes,
installed rapid transit corridors and integrated the ticketing and payment
structure (Puchar et al, 2005)1.
In Bangladesh the sufferings of the travelers
and passengers keeps growing by leaps and bounds through the presence of the
hassle of buying tickets for every travel, searching for ticket counters,
waiting at queue at ticket counters, resorting to the inconsistent fare
demanded by every transport mode, time wasted at ticket purchasing, black
ticketing etc. To solve these issues, the research paper wishes to draw light
into the probable means and suggests a digitalized technical model which can be
applied to streamline the issue and bring greater convenience and faster
service.
2. LITERATURE REVIEW:
Adequate and up-to-date transport and
communication system is imperative to understand a country’s growth potential.
According to the Ministry of Finance of the government of Bangladesh, transport
sector contributes to 6.58% of total GDP of Bangladesh (MOF annual report,
2013-2014)2. The transport system can be broken down into – Road
Transport, Railway, Water Transport and Air transport where 80% of the national
traffic comes from road transport which runs by different transport modality
(World Bank, 2014)3. Of the available transport modes in roads and
highways, 20% is private cars and 13% is motorcycles while the rest depends on
either public or private bus service and other modes like CNG-driven 3-wheelers
and Rickshaws (World Bank, 2014)3.
Only very few number of transportation
facilities like proper infrastructure and vehicles can be found in the country.
Increasing demand, too many non-motorized vehicles and lack of proper traffic
management schemes are creating severe transport problem in urban Bangladesh
(Mahmood et al, 2009)4. If the
existing public transport system is lined with the Information Technology
enabled services, a further smart infrastructure for public transport could be
obtained (Chatterjee and Nath,
2014)5.
To develop the transport sector and align
it with the Digital Bangladesh perspective, the government of Bangladesh has
taken several steps. According to the 2014 Annual report of Bangladesh Road
Transport and Highways Department, the most noticeable changes in digitalizing
passenger transport are inclusion of E-ticketing system, SMART-PASS or S-PASS
card in BRTC Bus and establishment of Digital Toll Plaza. Such processes intend
to free the passengers from the risk of carrying paper money and saves time.
According to Simmel, the importance of substance as
just a technical issue, and predicted that physical form of money can be
avoided that limits the quantity of money where credit cards, EPS, and the
Octopus are some exemplars (Simmel, 1978)6.
Inclusion of online ticketing is surely the first step ahead for digitalized
transport. Apart from ensuring comfort to the passengers, the use of mobile
ticketing technologies also leads to profits from revenue management
perspective (Eisenhardt, 1989)7.
Under the ‘Development of Multimodal
Transport Web Portal with Mobile Interactivity’ project initiated by the Service Innovation fund of Access to Information Program, the
ministry of roads and Highways has started e-ticketing service for the public
transport modes like Bangladesh Railway, BRTC bus etc. from 2006. Of the
different bus routes, 3 routes have such online ticket booking and ticket
purchasing facility applicable to 98 buses. This service can be availed from
the 58 different e-ticket counters set on the three routes. Having such
specialized distribution channel can bring efficiency in the transport payment
process. According to studies done in China, such distribution channel inspires
customers to purchase e-ticket. This ensures cost savings for all parties (Chen
and Kang, 2007)8. Moreover, if service providers adopt modern IT to
manage revenues, they will undoubtedly gain higher efficiency in transaction
(Li et al., 2009)9.
Meanwhile, having only e-ticketing facility
is not adequate for today’s changing customer demand in the transportation
scenario. Customer’s opinions, needs and urgency are changing hence, the
service providers need to look at factors which matches the customer’s taste.
Of the many factors influencing the purchasing and payment process in today’s era,
the crucial factor explaining whether consumers are likely to switch to a
mobile payment service is ease of use (Arvidsson and Peitersen, 2013)10.
To remove the hassle of buying tickets in
queue or having to browse web-portals to confirm e-tickets, the concept of
SMARTCARD with NFC technology or other microchip features came into view.
Purchasing of such Smartcard removes the need to buy tickets for every
individual transportation activity and offers easy recharging of amounts and is
not dependent on internet connectivity for every user. For the government-owned
bus service like BRTC such services has been enabled where SMARTCARD has been
termed as SMART-PASS or S-PASS. S-PASS service is available for 2 routes namely
Mirpur-Motijheel route and Abdullahpur-Motijheel
route. Introduced in April 2012, S-PASS has been activated in 116 City buses
and 17 S-PASS ticket counters have been set up in the mentioned routes to
facilitate recharging amount in the card. As of 30 June 2014, around 30303
passengers have purchased S-PASS and are actively using this service.
However, such mechanism can be applied on
other private-owned bus services and can be extended to other transport modes
like taxicab, railway, and domestic flight. In addition, to implement nation-wide
digitalized transport management, several factors also need to be considered.
Those are - safety and security, schedule coordination, operating costs and
many more. Adequate space in station, co-ordination among agencies, passenger
in and out flow management, coordination of vehicular movement, cozy
environment and reliable equipment are also included in this list (Taylor et
al, 2009)11.
In case of toll fee and parking fee too,
the application of S-PASS can reduce the hassle of carrying money or to receive
payment slips. Transport systems are linked greatly with various taxes and
tolls. If these could be collected using a simple portal, that too available
online, the existing facility would simplify to a great extent, facilitate
cashless transaction, multi-purpose prepaid cards which can nationwide be used
for transport and toll can also save passenger’s time (Chatterjee
and Nath, 2014)12.
Meanwhile, transport sector typically
includes many stops and stations thus coordination about fare management, schedules
can not only save time but also ensure proper diffusion of information (Smart
et al, 2009)13.
Such ubiquitous approach is required as
while merchants are not willing to invest in the development of infrastructure
without critical mass of consumers but
consumers may not adopt to digital payment services if they cannot be used
everywhere (Mallat, 2007)14. Also, such
system greatly depends on how the technology can be blended into profitable
business strategy as diffusion of a technology greatly depends on the dynamism
in the technology and business environments (Lau et al, 2008)15.
In light of the existing system and
available literature, this research paper proposes a central, nation-wide
digitalized transport and fare management procedure taking passenger’s comfort
level in consideration.
3. METHODOLOGY:
The research attempted two paths to create
link between customer’s statuses with proposed system. To gain insight into the
customers’ habits, quantitative data was gathered by surveying the sample from
the population to find the generic travel pattern, modality of payment,
transport modes used, digital connectivity, Smartphone penetration, average
payment made and preference of fare management options. A pilot study was held
for this quantifiable data and was administered through online medium by a
structured questionnaire having 14 close ended questions with a snowball
sampling method through which respondents brought further set of respondents. A
total of 118 responses were registered in two-week survey duration. The
respondents were primarily from the urban Dhaka metropolitan city.
Another path which led to the development
of the suggested automated model was conceptualized through researching
secondary documents, articles and interpreting information provided in the
annual report of Bangladesh Roads and Highways Department.
4. FINDINGS:
Based on the replies of the respondents, it
can be inferred that majority of the passengers travel at least twice a day on
average.
Figure 1: Number of times people travel everyday
Moreover, they have also mentioned how much
they spend each day for transportation. Most of them have mentioned that they
spend around 51-100 Taka per day for transportation and the next largest group
have mentioned that they spend 101-300 Taka per day for traveling. Based on
these data, it can be easily decided what can be the minimum amount to be
recharged for the smart card.
Figure 2: Amount of money people spend for commuting daily
Respondents were also asked how they
recharge their mobile phones. Majority of them have replied that they use
services like Flexiload (Grameenphone)
or i-top up (Banglalink) to
recharge their mobile phones. They next largest group have mentioned that they
use Bkash or similar online banking services provided
by different banks to recharge their phones. Based on these findings, we can
suggest that the smart card can be reloaded using similar services to recharge
with convenience.
Figure 3: How people recharge their mobile phones
The respondents were asked whether they
prefer to buy tickets online and 67 percent of them have said that they do not
prefer to buy tickets online where as 95 percent of the respondents are smartphone users and among them, 87 percent have full-time
internet connection. Despite that, people do not yet feel that comfortable or
secure enough to buy tickets for buses and trains online.
Figure 4: Different modes of transportation used
The respondents were asked what mode of
transportation they use. Majority of them have replied private cars and
following closely behind is the group who use public buses. Since the
Government has decided to limit the number of private cars per family, if given
a choice to use prepaid rechargeable smart cards to buy tickets, a large number
of private car users will prefer to travel by public buses. Moreover, the
survey shows that majority of the respondents are students. If they students
are motivated to travel by public transport rather than private cars, this
could also solve the traffic congestion problem to some extent.
Moreover, the respondents were asked to rank three options – buying tickets physically, buying tickets online and using a prepaid rechargeable card according to their preferences. Highest number of respondents ranked prepaid rechargeable card first and the largest group of respondents ranked buying tickets physically third. This indicates that the prepaid rechargeable card is going to meet the demand of the dwellers of Bangladesh and thus make their day to day life a lot easier.
Figure 5: Ranking of different options to buy tickets
5. SYSTEM
DESCRIPTION:
Figure 6: Flowchart of NFC
Ticket Management System
The smart card will contain a microchip that will keep
track of payment information and monetary value stored in the card. The card is
swiped ensuring it is within the proximity of a smartcard processor and the
appropriate transaction cost is deducted from the stored-value of the card.
Whether taking public transportation or paying toll, the interaction mode is
consistent in all transactions. The core component of the system is the Fare
Management System which takes care of all the transaction related tasks and
transaction validation. The front-end smartcard processors which are setup at
different points and they act as the reader machines with which the users
interact. Local Data Processors can communicate with the Service Provider
Central Computer or database in real-time, the transaction data may be stored
offline and sent later on through the network.
This paper proposes a Near Field Communication (NFC)
Integrated Circuit (IC) chip smart-card system for this purpose. It is based on
the ISO 18092 standard. The NFC devices must be placed in very close proximity
of each other for peer-to-peer communication. That is why it is considered as a
popular choice for secure communication between devices. Moreover, NFC devices
can act both as a tag and a reader. This unique feature has made NFC a popular choice
for contactless payment. The NFC standard has three modes of operation:
I.
Peer-to-peer mode: It swaps data
between two devices
II.
Read/write mode: One active device
reads information from a tag or passive device
III. Card
emulation mode: An NFC device can act like a contactless smart-card
In addition
to that we have to keep the security issues in mind as well. How the NFC
technology can be implemented by ensuring security is given below:
I. NFC enabled chips in card or phone can be only skimmed if
spoofing device is within few centimeters of distance from the chip. This makes
NFC technology more secure than the other contemporary methods.
II. The recent commerce apps
store payment information solely on the device. The card information is
encrypted and exclusively used by the intended parties after verification.
III. In addition to that, they
use SSL (Secure Socket Layer) technology to protect financial information.
Furthermore, NFC Antenna in Android phones are only activated only when the
phone is both on and unlocked.
IV.
For the smartcard with NFC capabilities, sleeves can be used
to deflect radio frequencies from snooping into the card’s NFC chip.
We
have selected Near Field Communication as our basis of the system because all
the above mentioned advantages.
6.1
Registration
Since
registration of this card will include entering the details of the customers
into the system, it involves a lot of data entry work. To expedite such time
consuming work, National ID, Driving license or passport can be used to create
account quickly. The users will be given a Unique ID number and password. So
when the user wants to use the existing online system to purchase ticket in
advance for Domestic flights, Trains, Intercity Buses, they can just login
using their ID and password and purchase tickets with their smart-card without
filling up lengthy forms. Moreover, it will ensure data integrity across
different systems. Recently Government of Bangladesh has started the process of
SIM reregistration. Once complete, one's SIM details
can also be used during registration process as well.
6.2
Recharge and Balance enquiry
Initially the smart-card will be
topped up with certain amount. This paper proposes installation of Automated
Ticket Vending Machines (ATVMs) at prominent locations near stations where customers
can check their cards usage details. This paper also proposes linking various
Bank Accounts or Bkash Account of the customers to
smart-card so that the customers will be able to recharge their smart-cards
using the ATVMs. Since most of the customers carry NFC enabled smartphone now-a-days, this paper proposes to add an
Android application which can be easily downloaded by the customers. After
installing the App, if customers bring the smart-card near the smartphone, using NFC they can easily check their card
balance and transaction details whenever they want.
6.3 Various transportation and services are
divided into the following categories:
Figure 6: Fare Management System
Outline
6.3.1 Road Transports
6.3.1.1
Bus
6.3.1.2
Taxi Cab
/ Auto Rickshaw
Buses, Taxi Cabs or Auto Rickshaws will have NFC
devices installed which uses wireless network. Once the passenger gets in and
holds his or her smart-card near NFC reader, his/her location and time details
are captured. After they reach the destination, they hold their cards again
near the NFC reader and this time based on the previous data, fare is
calculated and passenger’s account balance is checked and finally, due amount
is deducted from their smart-cards. Upon both successful check-in and
check-out, the NFC reader will display green light. In case the passenger does
not have enough balance in account, at check-out, a red light signal will be
displayed with a beep. In case of intercity buses, if anyone wants to buy the
ticket earlier, he/she can do so in advance either online or from ticket
counters. In such cases, traditional mode of payment can be used since we
cannot completely get rid of it due to cases like insufficient fund. That data will be stored in the smart-card as
an e-ticket. On the day of travel, they can just use the smart-card at the
device installed inside the bus. In case of minibus, Taxi cab or Auto Rickshaw,
if the installation process or costing of NFC reader device does not seem to be
feasible, the latest smartphones can be easily used
to read the smartcards.
6.3.2
Rail
Transports
In case of railways, ticket management system will
work just like intercity bus tickets. There will be gates right before getting
into the train and if someone has already reserved the ticket, the amount it
paid in advance but if they just come to the station on the day of travel,
their ticket fare will be deducted on that day itself.
6.3.3 Air Transports
Domestic air tickets will be handled just like the
intercity but tickets or rail tickets but in addition to that air tickets might
require verification that a different person is not traveling under the
reserved ticket. It can be easily checked by the officials since during
registration, client’s photo is also saved.
6.3.4
Water
Transports
Launches can use the same mechanism for ticket
management that is mentioned above.
6.3.5
Transport
related services
6.3.5.1
Toll
6.3.5.2
Parking
This paper proposes to install NFC reader devices at
all the toll points and parking lots. The customers can pay for the services
just by using their smart-card rather than carrying cash.
6.3.6
Further
scope for expansion
6.3.6.1 Fuel Station
6.3.6.2 Fitness
6.3.6.3 Maintenance and repair
6.3.6.4 License Application and Renewal
People can also use the smart-card to pay the dues at
the fuel stations. Transport owners have to pay fees for various purposes like
annual fitness, maintenance and repair, License application and registration.
The user can pay these fees easily using the smart-card. That will save a lot
of time and trouble. These facilities will be provided in future.
6.4
Reporting
Lost Card
This paper proposes setting up a hotline number for
customer care. In case any customer loses the smart-card he/she can call the
hotline and report it. The card will be blocked immediately and amount left in
the card will be transferred to the customer's bank account.
6.5
Cancellation
of Tickets
In case the reservation is cancelled by the authority,
the amount will be refunded by them to the smart-card of the customer and a
notification SMS will be sent to the customer's Mobile phone. If the customer
himself or herself cancels the reservation, notification will be send to their
Mobile phone and the authority will deduct any fee applicable following their
policy and refund the remaining amount to the customer's mart card.
It is predicted that by next few years, most of the smartphones will be NFC enabled. Moreover, from the survey
we have found out that almost everyone is using smartphones
in their day-today lives. Based on all these information, the smartcard based
system can be replaces by the e-wallet based system by collaborating with the
Telecommunication and Financial Partners. Data migration or system restructure
will not be that costly or time consuming since the e-wallet will use NFC
technology as well. If required, both the smartcard and the e-wallet can be
used simultaneously during this migration period.
8.
CONCLUSION:
As Bangladesh is getting digitalized in most of the
systems offering technology-based service platforms to make life easier for the
huge population, such proposed system in the transportation sector can deeply
affect the convenience level of numerous commuters. The broad the scope of the
system that can be materialized, the more streamline the system would be
facilitating the monitoring issues too. Also, such system can also result in
large number of employment generation in IT sector. The system also reduces the
ability of the transport companies especially the private transportation to
change per unit fare as the price vs. distance would be locked centrally to
enable the system to perform smoothly. Hence, it can also reduce customer’s
losing extra money on each travel and eliminated haggling with fare along with
black ticketing. However, the research was conducted on a very limited scale
and was only confined into urban Dhaka as sample hence a bigger level of survey
mechanism can be administered into future publication. Also, the viewpoints of
the authority especially of the concerned ministry as well as impact study of
such services are also interesting avenues to research further in this area.
1. Pucher, J., Park, H., Kim, M. H., and Song, J.
(2005). Public transport reforms in Seoul: innovations motivated by funding
crisis. Journal of Public Transportation, 8(5), 3.
2.
Annual
report (2013-2014), Bangladesh Roads and Highways Division, Government of the
people’s republic of Bangladesh, available at:
http://www.rthd.gov.bd/assets/docs/annual_report_2013-2014.pdf
3.
Bangladesh
Country Report (2014),World Bank, available at: http://data.worldbank.org/country/bangladesh
4.
Mahmood, M. O. N. O. W. A. R., Bashar, M. A., and Akhter, S. (2009). Traffic Management System and Travel
Demand Management (TDM) Strategies: Suggestions for Urban Cities in Bangladesh.
Asian Journal of Management and Humanity
Sciences, 4(2-3), 161-178.
5.
Chatterjee, P., and Nath, A. (2014).
Information Technology in public transports of India–A ubiquitous approach. International Journal, 2(10).
6.
Simmel, G. (1978). The philosophy of money, trans. T. Bottomore
and D. Frisby. Abington,
England: Routledge.
7.
Eisenhardt, K. M. (1989). Building theories from case study
research. Academy of management review,
14(4), 532-550.
8.
Chen,
L. H., and Kang, F. S. (2007). Integrated vendor–buyer cooperative inventory
models with variant permissible delay in payments. European Journal of Operational Research, 183(2), 658-673.
9.
Li, G.,
Yang, H., Sun, L., and Sohal, A. S. (2009). The
impact of IT implementation on supply chain integration and performance. International Journal of Production
Economics, 120(1), 125-138.
10.
Arvidsson, A., and Peitersen, N.
(2013). The ethical economy: Rebuilding
value after the crisis. Columbia University Press.
11. Taylor, B., Iseki, H., Miller, M. A., and
Smart, M. (2009). Thinking outside the bus: Understanding user perceptions of
waiting and transferring in order to increase transit use. University of California, Berkeley, Partners for Advanced Transit and
Highways (PATH).
12.
Chatterjee, P., and Nath, A. (2014).
Information Technology in public transports of India–A ubiquitous approach. International Journal, 2(10).
13.
Smart,
M., Miller, M. A., and Taylor, B. D. (2009). Transit stops and stations:
transit managers’ perspectives on evaluating performance. Journal of public transportation, 12(1), 4.
14.
Mallat, N. (2007). Exploring consumer adoption of mobile payments–A
qualitative study. The Journal of
Strategic Information Systems, 16(4),
413-432.
15.
Lau, R.
Y., Wong, O., Li, Y., and Ma, L. C. (2008). Mining trading partners'
preferences for efficient multi-issue bargaining in e-business. Journal of Management Information Systems,
25(1), 79-104.
Received on 31.12.2015 Modified on 23.01.2016
Accepted on 27.01.2016 © A&V Publications all right reserved
Asian J. Management. 2016; 7(2): 80-86.
DOI: 10.5958/2321-5763.2016.00012.3